economics

stock to flow

Stock-to-flow is a ratio that measures how much of a commodity exists in total stock relative to how much new supply is produced each year, used to quantify scarcity.

Stock-to-flow is a concept borrowed from commodity analysis, originally used to evaluate the scarcity of precious metals like gold and silver. The stock refers to the total existing supply of an asset. The flow refers to the amount of new supply added each year through production or mining. Dividing the stock by the flow gives the stock-to-flow ratio: a higher number means it would take more years of current production to replicate the existing supply, implying greater scarcity. Gold has historically had a very high stock-to-flow ratio because it is nearly indestructible and accumulates over centuries, while newly mined gold each year is a small fraction of total above-ground supply.

Bitcoin's stock-to-flow ratio increases with each halving because the flow (new block reward) is cut in half approximately every four years while the stock continues to grow. Before the 2024 halving, around 900 new bitcoin were produced daily. After the halving, that dropped to roughly 450. As the stock grows and the annual new supply shrinks, the ratio rises. A pseudonymous analyst known as PlanB popularized the stock-to-flow model for Bitcoin around 2019, arguing that Bitcoin's scarcity, quantified by this ratio, correlated historically with its market value.

Stock-to-flow is a descriptive framework for understanding Bitcoin's supply mechanics, not a price prediction tool. The model attracted significant attention during periods when its forecasts appeared to match price movements, and equal skepticism when they diverged. Critics point out that a model based solely on supply-side mechanics cannot account for demand, adoption, regulation, or market sentiment, all of which influence price significantly. CanoeBit presents stock-to-flow as an educational concept about Bitcoin scarcity, not as investment guidance.

Frequently asked questions

Is stock-to-flow a reliable way to value Bitcoin?

Stock-to-flow describes Bitcoin's supply mechanics accurately, but its use as a price valuation tool is contested. The model has periods of close historical fit and notable divergences. Price is determined by supply and demand together; a model that only accounts for supply cannot capture demand-side factors like adoption, regulation, macroeconomic conditions, or market sentiment. It is most useful as an educational framework for understanding scarcity, not as a forecasting instrument.

How does Bitcoin's stock-to-flow compare to gold?

After the 2024 halving, Bitcoin's stock-to-flow ratio surpassed gold's for the first time, meaning it takes more years of current Bitcoin production to match the existing stock than it does for gold. Gold has traditionally had among the highest stock-to-flow ratios of any commodity, around sixty to seventy, which is one reason it has been used as a store of value for thousands of years. Bitcoin's ratio will continue to rise with each halving until production effectively reaches zero.

Who is PlanB and why is the model associated with them?

PlanB is the pseudonym of a Dutch institutional investor who published a widely read analysis in 2019 applying the stock-to-flow concept to Bitcoin. The paper argued that Bitcoin's historical price data showed a statistically significant relationship between its stock-to-flow ratio and market capitalization. The model gained mainstream attention and was extended to include cross-asset comparisons with gold and silver. PlanB's forecasts have been both praised when prices appeared to follow the model and criticized heavily when they did not.