MSCI Adopts Index Exclusion Rule That Flagged Strategy and Metaplanet for Deletion

NewsBlock · 972,1657 min read
AI-assisted

AI helped with research and writing. The editor chose topic and angle, decided what stays in and approved the article. Sources at the end.

How we work

Index provider MSCI announced on October 15, 2026 that it will exclude "non-operating companies" from its Global Investable Market Indexes, a rule that, in MSCI's own simulation, deletes Strategy, the largest listed holder of bitcoin, and Metaplanet. The index exclusion takes effect at the close of November 30, and Strategy's shares closed 9.56% lower on the first trading day after the announcement.

What MSCI decided

MSCI published the decision at 20:48 GMT on October 15, one day before its own deadline. It will implement the proposal from its August 3 consultation "with minor modifications" and did not specify what those modifications are. The rule applies from the November 2026 Index Review.

Investment funds, business development companies and other passive vehicles were already ineligible. MSCI now adds corporate issuers with similar characteristics, identified through new quantitative screens. The final list of affected companies follows on November 11.

In the same announcement, MSCI ended the interim measures it had applied since October 2025 to companies whose digital assets made up 50% or more of total assets. Those measures froze increases in their share counts and inclusion factors and deferred new additions. From the November review on, these companies are assessed under the new screen instead.

How the screen works

The test has two stages. MSCI first checks whether a company has substantial operating assets. According to the August consultation, a company passes this core screen if operating assets exceed half of its total assets.

A company that fails is measured against five financial ratios and becomes ineligible if it is flagged on four or more. The thresholds MSCI proposed in August were operating assets below 20% of total assets, operating expenses below 5% of total assets, negative operating cash flow, non-operating fair-value changes above 5% of total assets and a dependence on external capital above 20%. The announcement of October 15 does not say which of these values the modifications change.

The rule is stricter for newcomers than for current members. A company outside the index is barred if it fails in either of its two most recent annual filing periods. A current constituent is removed only if it fails in each of them. Buffers apply both to the thresholds and to the timing of additions and removals.

Flow diagram of MSCI's two-stage screen. Stage one asks whether operating assets exceed 50% of total assets, and a company that passes stays eligible. A company that fails is tested against five ratios: operating assets below 20% of total assets, operating expenses below 5% of total assets, negative operating cash flow, non-operating fair-value changes above 5% of total assets and dependence on external capital above 20%. Four or more flags make it ineligible. A current constituent is removed only if it fails in both of its two latest annual filing periods.
MSCI's screen as proposed in August 2026. The thresholds may change with the minor modifications MSCI announced on October 15.

Who failed the screen in MSCI's simulation

MSCI applied the proposed screen to the MSCI ACWI IMI as of May 2026. Three constituents would have been deleted: Strategy with a float-adjusted market capitalization of 23,931 million dollars, Yellow Cake with 1,807 million and Metaplanet with 654 million.

Three more companies would have gone on a public watchlist: Center Laboratories from Taiwan with 673 million dollars, Lydia Holding from Turkey with 319 million and SharpLink from the USA with 165 million. By our calculation, Strategy accounts for 86.9% of the combined 27,549 million dollars of all six companies.

Bar chart of the float-adjusted market capitalization of the six companies flagged in MSCI's May 2026 simulation, in million dollars. Deleted: Strategy 23,931, Yellow Cake 1,807, Metaplanet 654. Public watchlist: Center Laboratories 673, Lydia Holding 319, SharpLink 165. Strategy accounts for 86.9% of the combined 27,549.
Six companies, one dominant position: Strategy is 86.9% of the market value MSCI's simulation flagged.

Yellow Cake holds physical uranium. The screen does not name bitcoin anywhere, and it reaches companies whose balance sheet consists mainly of a held asset, whatever that asset is.

The simulation is not the final list. MSCI applies the screen to the latest filings and publishes the result on November 11. Strategy has been a member of the MSCI World Index since May 2024 and, according to its latest purchase announcement, holds 848,250 bitcoin.

How MSCI got here

This is MSCI's second attempt. On October 10, 2025, it opened a consultation on excluding companies whose digital assets make up 50% or more of total assets. In November 2025, JPMorgan analysts estimated that an exclusion of Strategy could trigger about 2.8 billion dollars in passive outflows.

On January 6, 2026, MSCI decided not to exclude these companies at its February review. It froze their share counts in its indexes instead and announced a broader consultation on non-operating companies in general. Strategy's shares rose 6.6% in after-hours trading that day. The broader consultation followed on August 3 and closed on September 30.

What Strategy argues

Strategy answered the consultation on August 31 with a letter signed by Executive Chairman Michael Saylor and CEO Phong Le. The company calls the proposal a pretext for targeting digital asset treasury companies and a repackaged version of the 50% rule MSCI dropped in January. It argues that the terms "operating" and "non-operating" have no basis in U.S. GAAP, IFRS or any recognized legal framework, and that Strategy reports its bitcoin business as an operating segment under U.S. GAAP, consistent with discussions with SEC staff.

Strategy also says the stakes for its own shares are small. According to the company, funds tracking MSCI's Global Investable Market Indexes hold about 13 million shares, or 3.1% of basic shares outstanding. That equals 60% of the average daily trading volume of MSTR over 30 days. Le described a possible exclusion as immaterial to the company at an investor Q&A on August 18.

How the market reacted

Strategy's shares closed at 151.29 dollars on October 15, before the announcement. On Friday, October 16, the first session after it, they closed 9.56% lower at 136.83 dollars. The decline did not happen in isolation: the Nasdaq Composite lost 2.14% the same day, while bitcoin traded near 82,000 dollars, about 2% above the day before.

The outcome had been priced in for weeks. On Polymarket, the market on whether Strategy leaves the MSCI World or MSCI USA index by December 31, 2026 stood at 36.5% on July 20 and at 94% on October 19.

What an exclusion does and does not touch

Index membership decides which passive funds have to hold a share. It does not decide what a company owns, and nothing in MSCI's rule requires Strategy to sell bitcoin or affects its Nasdaq listing. Why access to passive money matters for a company that funds its bitcoin purchases by issuing shares is the question behind our analysis of who buys bitcoin after Strategy. Why large institutions wait for permission before they hold bitcoin is the subject of our essay Fail Conventionally.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. The rule decides which shares index funds may hold, not what a company owns. An exclusion would not end the Nasdaq listing of MSTR and does not require Strategy to sell any bitcoin.

On November 11, 2026. MSCI publishes the final list with its November Index Review announcement, and the changes take effect at the close of November 30.

Because the screen does not look at bitcoin at all. Yellow Cake holds physical uranium, and the test flags companies whose balance sheet is mostly a held asset rather than an operating business.

Sources

  1. 1.MSCI — Results of the Consultation on the Eligibility of Non-Operating Companies in the MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes (October 15, 2026)
  2. 2.MSCI — Consultation on Eligibility of Non-Operating Companies for the MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes (August 2026)
  3. 3.Strategy — Response to MSCI's Consultation on Eligibility of Non-Operating Companies (August 31, 2026)
  4. 4.The Block — Strategy, Metaplanet could face MSCI index removal under new proposal (August 14, 2026)
  5. 5.Decrypt — Saylor Urges MSCI to Drop 'Discriminatory' Rule That Would Delete Strategy (September 1, 2026)
  6. 6.Blockspace — MSCI retains Strategy in indices, keeps door open for other bitcoin treasuries (January 7, 2026)
  7. 7.Seeking Alpha — Strategy gets to remain in MSCI indexes, stock gains over 6% (January 7, 2026)
  8. 8.Cointelegraph — Strategy's Michael Saylor on potential MSCI exclusion: 'We're engaging'
  9. 9.Cointelegraph — MSCI adopts index exclusion rules that could oust Strategy (October 16, 2026)
  10. 10.MarketBeat — Strategy (NASDAQ:MSTR) Shares Gap Down (October 16, 2026)
  11. 11.TIKR — Strategy Stock Fell Nearly 10% in a Day After MSCI's Index Decision (October 17, 2026)
  12. 12.24/7 Wall St. — Prediction Markets Are Pricing Real Risk Into MicroStrategy's Bitcoin Bet (July 20, 2026)
  13. 13.Polymarket — Microstrategy delisted from MSCI index by December 31?

Not financial advice. CanoeBit publishes educational content only. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any asset.